Dartmouth Outing Club Design Challenge

Experience Design

Starting Challenge

The Dartmouth Outing Club is the oldest and largest collegiate outing club in the country. The club serves over 1,500 students per year and is the largest undergraduate club on campus. Part of the mission of the Dartmouth Outing Club (or DOC) is to "to further, through camaraderie in the out-of-doors of a diverse and inclusive membership." However, demographic surveys of the DOC have consistently shown that the club does not reflect the makeup of the Dartmouth student body, particularly racially and socioeconomically. Stories from students also indicate that the DOC can be an exclusive space that makes getting started with its outdoor activities difficult. Both higher education institutions and the outdoor recreation community in the United States have a long history of systematically excluding marginalized communities from participation. In an effort to address these inequities, we asked the question:

How might we make the Dartmouth Outing Club a more inclusive and welcoming space for anyone who might have an interest in the outdoors?

My Role

I initiated, planned, and managed this project with mentorship from Design For Change USA. I worked with a team of six other student designers.

The Result: Two New Opportunities for Engagement

Design Process: Feel, Imagine, Do, Share

We used Design for Change's approach to the design process, engaging in the steps of Feel, Imagine, Do, Share.

Feel

Background Research

We used Facts-Questions-Quotes-Connections charts to gather information and thoughts from outside resources on equity and inclusion in the outdoors, including podcasts, videos, and articles. We also filled out this chart ourselves so we could pool our collective knowledge and learn where each of us was starting from regarding these issues.

Facts-Questions-Quotes-Connections chart from background research on equity and inclusion in the outdoors Facts-Questions-Quotes-Connections chart from background research on equity and inclusion in the outdoors

Facts-Questions-Quotes-Connections charts from our background research

User Research

We used our findings from background research to brainstorm interview questions and tested those questions by interviewing each other. We then conducted over 24 interviews with Dartmouth students and community stakeholders. We talked with student leaders and participants in the DOC, but we also emailed the entire undergraduate student body and talked with students who had not been involved in the club before.

We used a number of design tools to thoroughly analyze our insights from interviews. A journey map helped us understand what a typical path might look like for getting involved in the DOC, and creating three personas allowed us to examine how those paths might differ based on people's identities and backgrounds.

Journey map for getting involved in the Dartmouth Outing Club Three personas representing different student paths and backgrounds in relation to the DOC

Journey map and personas developed from interview research

We also used Design for Change's Root Cause Analysis framework to connect the symptoms of the problems we uncovered with their root causes. These tools and analyses led us to narrow down on our central How Might We question: "How might we reframe the goals of the DOC to allow for multiple definitions of successful membership in order to improve accessibility and inclusivity, particularly in a world with online social events and local trips only?"

Imagine

Brainstorming and Narrowing Ideas

We held two brainstorming sessions with a total of nine prompts to generate a wide range of ideas, then narrowed down our favorites with dot-voting and discussion. After storyboarding these ideas, we took them to student leaders to get feedback and think through the details of their feasibility.

Our biggest challenge was balancing our ideas with our constraints. As the summer went on, it became apparent that we were designing not only for inclusivity, but for inclusivity during a pandemic. In hindsight, we would have gained a lot from asking people about what worked well and what needed improvement in their interactions with clubs and communities during the remote spring term. We also held out hope for a long time that one of our ideas — an intro event for the DOC — could be held in person. Once Dartmouth confirmed it would be holding classes remotely for the fall term, we shifted our focus to solutions that were entirely virtual or compatible with campus COVID guidance.

After gathering feedback, we narrowed down our two final deliverables: a fall intro event for the DOC, and a new leadership position that would function as a general leader.

Do

Building Into Existing Structure

It was key that we built our solutions into the existing structure of the Dartmouth Outing Club. For our new leadership position, we consulted with our Outdoor Programs advisors, the Student Risk Management committee, and DOC club chairs while writing up our documentation. We learned that if trips were run closer to the college and didn't venture into the backcountry, leaders would be allowed to lead trips with a regular CPR/First Aid med cert rather than a wilderness one — cutting hours off of the total time needed for training. We settled on calling the position a "Local Leader."

For the intro event, we worked with the current DOC club officers to plan and deliver a presentation that gave a comprehensive overview of the DOC and detailed the ways to get involved even if you had minimal outdoor experience.

Share

Embedding Our Work for the Long Term

We presented our work to the DOC at the termly inclusivity event. We also wrote the details on how to run the inclusivity event into the DOC officer manuals and moved all of our Local Leader materials into the DOC shared drives to be accessed in the future. I became the Local Leader coordinator for the next year along with another student. We ran the trainings, onboarded new leaders, and sent emails outreaching to potential local leaders across campus.

The DOC Intro Event has been run for three consecutive years now, and the Local Leader position still exists with two new student coordinators and Outdoor Programs advising.

Gallery